Carrie Nassif: “Last Lunch”

By Carrie Nassif

‍ ‍

“This is your mother, Ardell,” she had begun when she called in November seven years ago to invite me and my sister to a Christmas Eve dinner.

I hadn’t seen her since I was 18 and had used up all of two paychecks for a flight to Florida. I knocked on the door of the condo she’d kicked me out of three years earlier, and knocked and knocked until she hollered to me that she’d call the police. I invited her to go ahead. I parroted what she’d told me when the SRS investigation had come back with no findings, “like you say, mom, you’re an attractive white woman, and no one wants to get involved in a domestic affair.” 

She pushed my younger sister through the smallest opening she could make in the door and stood there, listening. I haven’t seen my mother since. 

I did call her when my child graduated college. I was driving to the lake at the college town where the party was being held and I felt a strange pang of my mother’s absence. A part of me wanted to know if she had ever really existed at all. “We both raised strong daughters,” I told her – surprised she’d answered the phone, surprised by her voice so similar to her mother’s, surprised how hollow her accusations felt to me by then. How sad I felt for her afterwards. How palpable her unhappiness. 

I was not expecting to hear from her again, especially not six years later, when she called me back that first November.  

By then, my face was already aging into what I remember her looking like. I had ordered a white-blonde wig online and got samples of turquoise contacts in order to inhabit her from the inside out. I toyed with the notion of seeing her again and tried to imagine how she had endured the passage of time, let myself think of her as maybe even a little frail. I wanted to be able to see for myself, to see right through her pretty mask of bleached hair, dark rouge and doe eyes, her sharp fingernails.  A few years before when I’d been visiting my sister, we’d gone to the mall our mother worked at, the one she’d evaded my sister and her son at, and hoped for a glimpse. I’d twice circled both levels of the Macy’s, heart pounding, but nothing.

I would have flown out to see her. Would have loved an excuse to see my sister and her family. I would have booked it the day she called, but the roof was being replaced and I had a total knee replacement scheduled for December 22nd. I told her we could meet in the summer when I usually visited, but she was adamant that it had to be on Christmas Eve or nothing. “I guess I’ll see you in heaven, then,” she said and hung up. 

I shouldn’t have been so surprised that she thought she was going to go upward when she died. 

She called again, two Novembers later and invited me and my sister to Christmas Eve dinner, just the three of us. “It’s three hours in 30 years, Carrie,” she said, “you owe me that.” Nevermind that she had it mixed up who owed who what, it was early COVID times. I was working from home, only leaving to go the grocery store masked up. It made no sense to risk the pandemic for someone who didn’t want to meet my child or spouse, who refused to meet for lunch instead of dinner so that the rest of us could share the holiday (and my brother in law’s birthday) with our families. But she was incensed and declared us both dead to her. 

My mother left multiple unhinged and rage-filled voicemails that December, including one inviting us both to Christmas Eve dinner for the upcoming year, “take your time, but I need to know ASAP because I might have other plans.”

By then, I was curious about her need to see us, her uncharacteristic neediness cloaked in anger, her willingness to beg – but I didn’t call back.

I pictured the meal we might have had, my sister, my mother and me at a very nice restaurant sitting down to a table. Our kids and spouses, unbeknownst to our mother, seated at different tables to see just who this mystery person was, perhaps even with surreptitious video-taping capabilities. We all scootch into the white table cloth draped between us wondering what she could possibly have to offer, or want she could possibly want from us.

My partner at the time was working on a degree in cybersecurity and practiced his skills on my mother. Her phone was registered to an alias she had used when I was 13, when she had a set up a series of fraudulent credit cards that she had used to furnished our apartment, and purchase cocktail rings for every finger while we went hungry. We found that she had at least 17 other aliases using strange variations of her name, and of her second ex-husbands’ birthdate, all tied back to her address. 

I imagine a dinner with my mother while I think about my mother’s being two kinds of unwell: was she involved in some other kind of money-making scheme? Or was her identity so fractured from her early and cumulative trauma that each name represented a different personality part or identity status? Either way, it was impossible to imagine her being tender, vulnerable, or kind in our presence. Her telephonic righteous protestations and claims of entitlement were ever stronger, more twisted over time, and yet, she kept calling. My sister and I joked at first that maybe the voices in her head were telling her to sacrifice us on Christmas Eve. But it was also a little sobering. Chilling even. 

My mother called again, last year in the fall, while both my sister and I were going through protracted divorces. I answered and offered to attend her invited meal, saying I would enjoy being with my sister for Christmas. My mother said she didn’t think we would come at all because she was no longer in Florida (a mile away from my sister whom she would not speak with). But I agreed to come anyhow, thinking I’d get a break from my spouse and visit other family along the way on the nine-hour drive to her new location. When I reported back that my sister had neither the financial or emotional resources to spend a holiday away without her kids, she called the whole thing off. “If I can’t have you both, I won’t do it!”

So now, it’s mid-summer, and I try to imagine what will happen this year. When my sister helped me move out, she reminded me that I’ll probably start getting her calls in a few months. Unless she doesn’t. Unless she can’t. The reality is, we would have no way to know if she had died. I picture another, a last lunch with my mother; with her and with me and with my sister because, apparently, we are a matching set. 

I place us all in another restaurant, maybe slightly less swanky, maybe in an assisted living community space, maybe a nursing home like our dad had already been to and passed away in a few years ago. I close my eyes and sense holding my yoga core into a strong, supported posture, breathing to stay calm and regulated and intentional. I’ll want to remember everything that she says. How her face has changed, even the way she’ll hold it. The slight jeer of her upper lip showing the tilted wear pattern of her upper teeth, the squinch of her cheek when she disagrees. Her Chloe perfume smell. Her interactions as performance. I’ll wonder as we sit there, if who she is, if how she acts, has always been nothing but an amalgam of whatever will benefit her most; a calculated algorithm all along, intent to be anything but the victim. This will distract me from her falsehoods, her contradictions, her bitterness, this wondering. It will temper the signs of her temper, her religious superiority, her condemnation of us, her dismissal of our selfhood outside of her. This pitchy song we both grew up in, punctuated by her cussing out of syntax. 

I realize that, whatever histrionics go on, neither of us will have spouses to film it. 

It will be our goodbye. It will be a relief. 

My sister and I will sit in the dark car in the parking lot in Florida or on the border of Iowa and Illinois on Christmas Eve and it will be quiet. It will either get too humid or too cold, so we’ll have to start the car. 

We will exhale and it will be easy, it will be so easy, to drive away. 

Previous
Previous

Maria Wasson: “Foraging for one last lunch”

Next
Next

Mary-Lynne Stadler: “Morse Code from the Other Side”