Lou Faber: “If Only”

By Lou Faber

Lunch With My Birth Mother

It is a small cafe, Wisconsin Avenue cutting through the heart of Georgetown. It is Saturday, the only choice as she would never take off work for a lunch with someone she would never see again. I am early. Out of character for me, but anxiety has a way of warping, speeding up time and I dare not be late. I wonder, as I stand on the sidewalk, if I would recognize her. The only photos I had were small images from her college yearbooks. But those were, for her, twenty years ago, and I know that I, at 40 looked nothing like I did at 20 that morning in the hotel mirror. But I hoped there would be some resonance, some genetic radar ping, that I would sense her approach.

I get a table by the window. My foot is tapping so much that those at a nearby table notice. She leans over to him and says, "Probably a first date, I remember ours." She is eerily right, for this is a first meeting, and love is certainly its guiding force. And she and I are the same age, that I insured. I smile at the couple, nod in seeming agreement. She approaches. At least I think it is her, stocky, but the headshots in the yearbook didn't disclose more than her smile. She seems nervous, scanning the room, perhaps looking for someone familiar but totally unknown. She sees me, offers a tight, nervous smile and approaches. I say "hello," and pull out her chair.

Her smile warms slightly. Before I can speak she says, "I suppose I have been looking forward to this day and dreading it in equal measure. You cannot tell the family." I remind her that I don't know the family, not adding that now she is dead, buried in the Jewish Cemetery on the hill overlooking the Kanawha River beside my grandparents and great grandparents.

"I know you must have many questions, and I'll do my best to answer them.  It's odd in that I once hoped this day would never happen, but now I'm glad it has," she says, her smile growing warmer, 

I increasingly feel like butter left out in a sunny window. "My father," I start, but she cuts in. 

"You know your father wasn't the man I described to the adoption agency. That was a lie, but a lie no one was ever to figure out. I had to tell them something, so I made him Jewish, and Portuguese, because my dearest friend at work was Portuguese. In retrospect it was a strange choice, I know, given how few Portuguese Jews there are. And I know you thought about searching for him, because the Agency would tell you that fact. But you didn’t, so at least I didn’t send you on that wild goose chase. But I know you now know that. So ask what you will, while there is still time.”

I think of asking why, but I know, had known all along. "Cut the sin by half if caught." It was both a statement and question. 

She replies, eyes lowered, "Yes, at least he could be Jewish. With some in our family I'm not sure which would be worse, giving birth while unmarried, or to a child only half Jewish." 

"Tell me about him." Open ended, certainly, but I have come to know her, even if we had never met. Jewish families are like that, endless stories. And the one child who never married was destined to be the favorite aunt or uncle. 

"I'll give you the short version, since you must already know more than I do. We met at a dance run by the U.S.O.  Funny thing is I never went to those things, but once again I was there for a friend. Have you seen him?" I nod in the affirmative. "Then you know he was good looking. More than a little like yourself,” she couldn’t help but laugh.

I don't disagree with her; I don't reject a compliment even if not fully deserved. And the Irish, German, English and Scottish in him had to be so different from the Jewish boys and men that were the expectation of her family, that filled her social history. 

"He was warm and funny, and I admit now his smile melted me. It was a weekend I will never forget. And that was before I discovered I was pregnant with you.” 

I know what is coming, I smile and my eyes urge her on. 

“I couldn’t tell my family. They were kind and loving, but in some ways very traditional. And I knew I couldn’t be a mother on my own, nor could I live with my family taking over my motherly duties, so adoption and silence was my only option. And I think it worked out well enough from what I have been able to see.” 

I want to disagree, to tell her that there had always been a hole, but that would inflict a wound too deep. And I try to put myself in her position, painful as it must have been, and offer a smile as a salve. 

“He was military, so I knew he wouldn’t be around, but that was okay, I wasn’t looking for anyone. I was happy with my life, happy as an aunt, although I had always wondered . . . .”

I know we order, but I don’t know what. We have wine. I stare like a lovestruck child. I want to know all about her life, but we agreed to meet at a common age when I was much younger than now, so she hadn't lived most of hers yet. What she had, she tells me. 

"My parents, your grandparents, married on New Year’s Day at the turn of the century and built their home, the one in which my siblings and I grew up. And you would have loved my six sisters and one brother, although all but Shirley were older than me. I really liked working for the government, and it was easy enough to get a job when the war broke out and I had to leave college when things got a bit tight at home. And once I started working for the Treasury Department, I never felt the pull to go back and finish college. Then it wouldn't have made much difference for a woman. And while I loved the family, I couldn't bear to carry my shame home for all to sense or question." 

She draws silent knowing I want more, knowing she has no more to offer. She touches my hand, stares at it as you would a newborn's and strokes the scar on my wrist. I can stare at her with a longing that defies language. As she fades away, I kneel and gently place a large pebble on her gravestone.

Previous
Previous

Mary-Lynne Stadler: “Morse Code from the Other Side”

Next
Next

Risa Kaparo: “The Legacy”