By Carolyn Choa
I have been watching a few things about the Turin Shroud on YouTube , which led to a fascinating documentary about Jesus’ ‘lost’ years in the East.
Like a lot of people, I have not paid any attention to the Turin Shroud. Partly because I bought the verdict decades ago that it was a Renaissance forgery (which has now been disproved), and partly because I have never believed in the physical resurrection of Christ, which made it problematic for me to have remained a catholic.
What I do believe is that Jesus was a charismatic and awakened teacher. Over the years a lot has been written comparing Christ’s esoteric teachings to Buddha’s, and they are pretty similar. But it was only relatively recently that I had heard stories about Jesus’ travels to the east, where he apparently learnt from various spiritual traditions including Buddhism. Some believe that he had become an adept yogi before returning home to spread the word. Records in India called him Issa. If this were true, it can make a lot of sense.
But what of the resurrection? They have now discovered that the Shroud had not been painted on, and that the texture and weave matched other burial shrouds of the first century. There was also pollen which correctly matched the region and season of the crucifixion etc etc.
Currently there seems to be no good explanation of how this negative image of a man had materialised. It has only the depth of a single thread, meaning that the image was created after the blood from thorns, nails and spear wounds had soaked through.
Some people thought it was the work of Leonardo Da Vinci. An experiment was set up relatively recently using only materials available in the 15th century to create a photograph on a linen shroud, and it came out looking like a mess.
After gazillion investigations by teams of scientists all over the world, it is now believed that the image was probably created in a flash of radiation. For catholics, this is proof enough of the physical resurrection of Christ.
So are they right? Did the radiation emerge on the point of resurrection, or at the point of death? Could it be that Christ’s advance yogic practice allowed him to control his breath so that he only seemed to have died on the cross, when he was merely near death? Was he, in a word, buried alive? In which case, did he radiate enormous energy on the point of death, inside the tomb, wrapped in a shroud?
It is always possible that the resurrection story was invented by his disciples in order to gain more following. Did the disciples, in a word, tell a lie in order to spread the truth?
Here is one suggestion - was the person who appeared in front of the tomb someone else, who looked like Jesus, and preached like him? I hear St Thomas may have been his twin, either physically or spiritually. I am not familiar with the gospels, but was there not also some mention of Christ having transformed in the way he looked? I guess if we wanted to believe in something badly enough, we can always convince ourselves and others.
The final alternative is what the Catholic Church believes, that Jesus died on the cross and was buried, and that somehow, in the same way that he had raised Lazarus from the dead, he was able to raise himself after three days, and then appear like a luminous being to his mother and disciples.
We can’t even agree on anything that happened a week ago, so who knows what happened 2000 plus years ago, when none of the gospels were written contemporaneously? Not to forget they were also translated into different languages, with subtle differences in nuance, gender and intention.
In any case why does it matter so much? Does Jesus dying like a human being render any of his teachings less wise, less compassionate? Does it make him possess any less of the divine spirit, which, he taught, we are all part of?
I don’t know what happened of course, but I do know that, like Horatio, there are more things in Heaven and Earth than are dreamt of in our philosophy!