By Tony Blass
When I receive advice, I always consider the source. Who is it coming from, what are their values and experience, and do they have a stake in the outcome? If I’m unsure of whether to take advice, I try to consult other sources, if only to ask for a second opinion. Because that’s what advice is: someone’s opinion. If I choose to take it, then it becomes my decision.
Unless you are being given directions you must follow, the moment you make your choice you take most of the responsibility for whatever the outcome happens to be. Advice, after all, can only be considered bad in retrospect.
Does that mean the advice-giver bears no fault or liability for the result of their advice, now adjudicated “bad?” I suppose it depends to some extent on their credentials and/or your reasonable expectation of expertise. Certainly, their culpability increases if money or other favors were exchanged for said opinion. But even then, you must ask yourself the value of your contribution in the exchange. Most mothers have told most children something like “you get what you pay for.” Cultural truisms generally earn their weight through history and experience.
As a rule I personally try to avoid giving direct advice for these reasons. I much prefer the collaborative process of sorting options and having a dialogue about the pros and cons of each. Some people may think of this kind of exchange as a sign of weakness or indecisiveness. It can be especially tricky when one is employed in the role of consultant, physician, or therapist. But even in the case of authoritative, and/or professional advice, I believe the taking of it involves at least some degree of acceptance of accountability.
When I take advice, that is, make my own decision based on the input of others, I try to let then go of an attachment to the desired outcome. I like to think I usually consider all the good options before taking advice, and then choose wisely to the best of my ability. My eighteen year old son had some very insightful advice for me recently about trust. Basically, that you have 2 options: you can trust and hope, or you can trust and verify. But in the second case, you’re not really trusting.
So, the expression really should be “trust OR verify.” And if you are taking advice from someone you are not sure you can trust, you have to ask yourself why you are taking that responsibility and just exactly how much verification are you willing or able to do. And then hope for the best outcome.